So what did everyone think?
My opinion: Carrie Underwood was thrown to the wolves. She's got the chops to sing the part but I equated her acting performance to a steamroller. There was no moment she wouldn't simply roll through. I enjoyed the set, the lighting was a strangely necessary hybrid of film/tv lighting and theatrical lighting, and I thought some of the costumes were amazing. I also thought some of the costume decisions were horribly unflattering to the leading lady occasionally making her look like a frappin' tank (I think specifically when they had her wedding dress layered underneath another costume).
It's hard for me to figure out how much traction this got in a national audience considering all my social media networks revolve around people who would watch this. I hope the ratings were good enough and strong enough that this becomes a new NBC tradition at the holidays. I'd love to see them continually put up and tear down sets at the old Grumman plant on Long Island every year and perform a live musical. And should they cast Carrie again next year, I'm sure she will have improved by leaps and bounds in her acting.
And for the love of all that is holy, give them a curtain call next year and bring in an audience to react to the performance. I felt so empty after the songs when they pushed right on without stopping.
Edit: I would also add that I find the general malaise I've seen coming from my friends in musical theater world a touch hypocritical. I include myself in some of my jokes I made last night, too but then again I never held myself to a standard where that was unacceptable.
But remember how everyone got up in arms about the
actress who ripped Into the Woods apart? I remember how there was talk about supporting those within the community and you shouldn't be a critical voice. I found it interesting that some of those same people who wrecked Morgan James were on social media ripping Carrie Underwood apart.