I just wanted to thank all of you for your great suggestions. After much debate, I ended up at Illinois Wesleyan University in Bloomington, IL due to the advice of an alum who runs the company I had been working with. It's a great school and from everything I've experienced so far, a perfect fit for me. Because it's a small liberal arts school I get a good variety of classes outside of the theatre department. And even though the theatre department itself is rather small, the faulty are amazing and the amount of talent the students possess blows me away.