One assignment I did as an undergrad really stands out.
We were given some broad sketches of a set and some notes from the various production departments, as well as a list of items the director required be incorporated into the design. (A revolving bookcase, a 3-foot-by-3-foot level surface suitable for tapdancing, etc.) The assignment involved converting all of this abstract information into a buildable set design, and then preparing a rehearsal plot. The cumulative assignment was taping that plot out within a set time limit. (20 minutes, IIRC.) We were marked on five major elements:
- Compliance with Equity and Ministry of Labour safety requirements/guidelines/policies.
- Successfully taping out the rehearsal plot. (They checked with compasses and rulers to make sure that every length and angle was correct.)
- Incorporating the advice and materials provided by the various departments, especially incorporating the Director's requirements. (This was actually a trick question: fulfilling one of the Director's requirements would have involved an Equity violation.)
- Demonstrating an understanding of the process, as opposed to the component parts. (The point of the exercise is that you get to see and understand how being careful and thorough [or cutting corners] early in the process can help you or trip you up down the road.)
- A written report incorporating your own notes on the set. (Potential dangers and risks, reasons why you made the decisions you did, what priorities you identified as being most important in devising a final solution...)
There was a portion of the mark for aesthetics, but it was by and large a process-and-safety mark. (Of course, this was in a non-conservatory program where we were required to take set design courses concurrently, and might not work as well in other learning environments.)