Okay, I dont know US schools, nor the selection process. So these are just some general tips:
Name means a lot when you are just getting started. In australia, for example, there are a number of places that offer courses in "Production", however there is one that will put you so far above the others it is not funny (The National Institute for Dramatic Arts). I have an uncle who is fairly high up in the University system here, and he basically told me as I grew up "Once you create a reputation for yourself, your educational roots often do not matter, however fresh out of school, it means everything. Choose a place that is recognised both nationaly and internationaly and you will have no end of work."
Some courses come with 'extras' that are damn useful. I mentioned NIDA above - their Production course comes with certified training for things like high access platforms, rigging, pyro etc and the extra certification that comes with those competencies. The course is also a hell of a lot harder than anywhere else, but for three years work, you come out able to be employed straight up, instead of needing to go and atain OH&S certification, First Aide, etc.
Look at course outlines and the background of the lecturers. Some of them are huge names that have decided to give up the gig and teach the next generation - Sometimes, if it comes down to two different places, the one with a well renouned lecturer certainly takes the cake - especially if you take the extra step and get to know them, because they just may be able to put you into contact with them, and later on in life you can do a little bit of name dropping (I hate name droppers, however if there is someone you know they have worked with before, you can 'chat about old times')
Basically, find out as much as you can about each place, and if they have open days, go and attend, they may be able to put you into contact with some past graduates and current students who will really give you an idea about the intricacies a glossy pamphlet cannot give.
Talking. That is the way things work.